Photo: Pan Ha', Dysart

For volunteers

If volunteering goes wrong

Advice for organisations on managing volunteering challenges, resolving problems and supporting positive relationships between volunteers and the organisations they work with.

Most people’s volunteering experiences are positive. However, if things do go wrong, it’s important to work out a course of action. 

See if you can work things out together.

Where possible, problems (or complaints) should be discussed between a volunteer and their supervisor or line manager first. This should happen through an ad hoc discussion or in a supervision meeting. 

Refer to the organisation's ‘Problem Solving’ procedure.

For problems which cannot be solved informally, organisations should have a Problem Solving procedure to follow. This should deal with complaints, problems, issues or concerns in a fair, consistent and equitable way. 

These procedures often have several stages. This gives volunteers the opportunity to appeal to higher levels of management, usually including: 

  • Their own supervisor 
  • Their supervisor’s manager 
  • The board of trustees or other governing body or a regional/head office representative (where appropriate)

Do I have any rights?

Paid employees have employment contracts, which usually includes grievance and disciplinary procedures. An employment contract also gives you other rights, such as the right to take your employer to an employment tribunal. 

As a volunteer, you won't usually have a contract. This means you won't have the same legal status and protections that paid workers have in the UK. 

Volunteers don't usually have the right to have an organisation follow proper investigative procedures when things go wrong. They also don’t have the right to appeal a decision made by the organisation. 

Reporting to OSCR

If a volunteer has a concern about how a Scottish charity is being run, they can report it to the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR) through OSCR's online Concern Form. OSCR does not accept charity complaints by phone or email.  

How to report to OSCR

  1. Raise the issue with the charity first, where appropriate, and be prepared to explain if this was not possible.  

2. Check whether the issue is something OSCR can investigate, such as:  

  • Charity funds or assets being at risk
  • Assets not being used for charitable purposes
  • Mismanagement or governance concerns
  • Conflicts of interest
  • Serious safeguarding concerns
  • Suspected fraud or criminal activity involving the charity

3. Complete the OSCR Concern Form online: https://www.oscr.org.uk/raise-a-concern/concern-form/ 

4. Provide as much evidence and detail as possible, including dates, people involved, and any supporting documents. OSCR will review the information and decide whether further inquiry is needed.  

Issues OSCR does not normally deal with

OSCR cannot usually investigate: 

  • Volunteer or employment disputes

  • Bullying or grievance matters

  • Service complaints

  • General disagreements between members or trustees

  • Fundraising complaints

Contacting Fife Voluntary Action

After these steps have been taken, if you still feel unhappy with the outcome you can contact Fife Voluntary Action to talk this through and to seek further advice. 

Get in touch

Finding a volunteering role, and help for organisations that involve volunteers.

E-mail [email protected]

Telephone 0800 389 6046